Racebending.com

Media Consumers for Entertainment Equality

Categories

“The Crow” Reboot Should Extend Opportunities

April 30, 2013

Relativity Media is remaking the cult classic film The Crow (1994). Although this iconic story is being brought back to the silver screen, the breakthrough progress made by The Crow in terms of minority representation will not be brought back.


Brandon Lee plays The Crow in the 1994 film.

As part of development for the film, the studio appears to be throwing upcoming (affordable) young white male actors at the project in hopes that one of them will stick. Over the past three years, the lead role has passed through Mark Wahlberg, Bradley Cooper, Channing Tatum, Ryan Gosling, James McAvoy, and Tom Hiddleston, with the latest casting rumors floating around Alexander Skarsgard.

All of these failed casting attempts point at one direction: it looks like twenty years later, The Crow will be rebooted without a lead actor of color.

A Comic Book Movie with a PoC Lead

The movie version of comic book character Eric Draven was originated by actor Brandon Lee (son of legendary martial artist Bruce Lee) in the 1994 film The Crow. Lee tragically died in an on-set accident before filming was completed. Draven was later portrayed by another multiethnic Asian American actor, Mark Dacascos, in the 1998 television series The Crow: Stairway to Heaven.

The character of Eric Draven was not solely, if at all defined, by the ethnicity of the actor portraying him. This was significant to actors from communities of color, who must struggle to avoid racially stereotypic roles.

“Brandon Lee’s Eric Draven was recognizably Asian American without having a particular reason for being Asian American. Then — and now — Asian American characters in cinema often seem to require some excuse written into the script to justify their ethnicity, as if the character was only made Asian American for a reason…Sometimes it’s refreshing to see an Asian American character who can just be.”Jenn, blogger at Reappropriate.com

Diversity in The Crow franchise

In addition to Draven–easily the most iconic “Crow”–several characters of color have also assumed the “Crow” persona in the franchise, including Joshua, a Native American farmer of the Crow Nation, and Mark Leung, a Chinese detective. There have also been a number of female Crows (Amy Carlisle, Iris Shaw, Hannah Foster) in the comics and also some white male Crows in direct-to-video movies and in the novels.

[It’s interesting to note that one of the Crows, Jared Poe from The Crow: The Lazarus Heart, was a gay photographer who becomes the Crow after he is framed for the murder of his lover. Poe then seeks justice with help from his lover’s twin, Lucrece. When the plot of novel was adapted to a movie, The Crow: Salvation, all LGBTQ elements were removed, including the Crow’s sexual orientation and Lucrece’s identity as a trans woman. (“Straight-washing” didn’t help the film, which was unceremoniously dropped by it’s theatrical distributor and had to go to direct-to-home-video.)]

“While, no, the Crow doesn’t HAVE to be Asian-American, it was one of the few, if any, American entertainment series/franchise that had Asian-Americans playing the lead. There are no shortage of roles for white actors. But for Asian-Americans — especially Asian-American men — there are pretty much zero.” – comment on Racebending.com Facebook page

The Crow is a superhero persona that has been embodied by a broad array of chracters, and there is a lot of precedence for having a unique lead when adapting this diverse franchise to the movies. A studio wanting to make a The Crow movie could make a film starring a male actor of color, a woman in an action role (still pretty rare these days), or even a action movie starring a gay anti-hero with a transgender heroine–all existing Crow characters in the books.


Leaked concept art of Bradley Cooper as The Crow

Understandably, changes will be made to franchises as they evolve and new creative talents will emerge to play iconic roles. But it’s hard not to view the proposed casting of white actors–who already have more opportunities than non-white actors–as a regression, particularly given the significance of Lee’s casting twenty years ago and The Crow franchise’s continued willingness to break the mold with diverse characters.

Twenty years later, The Crow remake does not seem to be going against the Hollywood mold when it comes to casting. It’s a loss of opportunity and doesn’t do justice to the franchise. If the studio is having difficulty securing a white male lead to play The Crow, it should extend the casting net to a more diverse pool of actors.

Categories: blog, History and Concepts
Tags: , , , , ,

About the Author

Marissa Lee is one of the co-founders of Racebending.com

Related Posts

  • steamboat28

    I don’t think this movie should be made at all, regardless of who they decide to cast.

  • Well I never had a problem with a white guy playing the Crow, but to be honest, when I think of the Crow I think of the version played by Mark Dacascoa. And to be totally honest, I think with the standard white actor will come a standard story, possibly some broody teenage like guy with no actual personality. Or maybe I am too cynical.

  • GabrielDudley

    Hear hear! I am always frustrated at the seeming unwillingness to diversify — I would love to see the producers of this remake casting a woman/poc/LGBTQ character as the lead.

  • happyappa

    I guess that site was updated and named Luke Evans to play the lead. No
    surprise it’s another White guy, who isn’t even American, and even
    though no one has heard of him, he’s White, so…

    This movie should not be remade. If they are so set on redoing it, then they should have found an APIA actor (this includes mixed race people too), it is not hard, but Hollywood loves to use that excuse. Or find other POCs, and it would be great if there were strong women, LGBTQ representation too. But small/no chance of that happening.

    Yeah the role isn’t race specific, but even when it is, it’s racebent or whitewashed for White actors to play. Spiderman is not race specific, but superfans couldn’t even live with the -concept- of a POC Peter Parker.

    If something originally had POC actors in it, and it is remade, it will be whitewashed. And this isn’t even an “overseas”, but an American movie. How many times have we seen Kmovies or Jmovies remade with White people in the leads. It’s not about “New setting in US = White”, but Whites will be in the lead roles no matter what. They ruin everything.

  • Phil

    Worst idea to remake The Crow, I certainly wont be watching it. The original was a cult classic .. and perhaps i’m biased but it’s the only movie I know of where the lead is a mixed white-asian male(my own genetic status :/ ) with a deep romantic relationship with a full-white woman *shock* *horror* and I would hate to see that tarnished.

    RIP Brandon Lee

  • Ren Chant

    just another terrific movie that they think they have to reboot and will ruin.

  • Lola Guin

    Brandon Lee was pretty white, like 5/8 to be exact (Bruce Lee was 1/4 German). He didn’t really look like a “person of color” in “The Crow”. I doubt most people considered him a “PoC” in “The Crow”, especially considering his name was “Eric Draven” (a pretty white sounding name) and he was covered in makeup the entire time. Just a thought. Personally, I don’t want this movie remade. He was perfect and no one will ever top his performance. I still get chills when I watch that movie. Let it be, Hollywood. Brandon was as good of an Eric Draven as you’re going to get. Such a beautiful man. He would have been such a big action star, in my opinion. It’s sad to see all that potential turn to ash because of a stupid mistake. RIP Brandon Lee.